This week's NFL Rookie Fantasy Football Start/Sit is all about rookies making the most of their opportunities or not. Six of the seven players mentioned could be taking on increased roles with their teams for one reason or another, but not all of them are taking advantage.
Which rookies should start, and which should sit, in fantasy football lineups for Week 11? Let's get into it.
NFL fantasy football rookie starts for Week 11
Start 'Em: Emmett Johnson

The matchup: The Kansas City Chiefs are facing the Arizona Cardinals this week. Arizona is 28th in the league in rushing yards allowed, 25th in passing yards per play to backfield targets, and the 13th-most favorable matchup to running backs in fantasy football.
Arizona is coming off a game where they were dominated in time of possession (42:23-17:37) and gave up over 200 yards on the ground.
Why I'm starting him: Last week, Emmett Johnson was the starting running back for the Chiefs with Kenneth Walker out due to injury. Johnson played 88 percent of the offensive snaps, carried the ball 22 times, and saw seven targets, all season highs.
Johnson was very productive with those opportunities. His 101 rushing yards gave him 4.59 yards per attempt, and he caught six of his seven targets for 70 yards and two touchdowns.
Both of his touchdowns came in the red zone last week. After a long catch-and-run score in Week 8 and a garbage-time carry from the six-yard line in Week 9, it was good to see Johnson as a focal point of the offense near the end zone.
It is unclear if Walker will play in the game against the Cardinals, but it's not trending in his direction.
Andy Reid on Kenneth Walker III: "He had a sore groin (last week). It's getting better. We just don't want to do something stupid. ... He's feeling better."
— Nate Taylor (@ByNateTaylor) November 18, 2026
If Walker is indeed ruled out of this game, Johnson is a must-start in fantasy lineups this week.
Fantasy outlook: RB2
Start 'Em: Jonah Coleman

The matchup: The Denver Broncos are facing the Las Vegas Raiders in a divisional matchup in Week 11.
The Raiders have become one of the worst defenses in the NFL after a fun start to the season on that side of the ball. They are 30th in rushing yards allowed, 25th in rushing touchdowns allowed, and the fifth most favorable matchup for running backs in fantasy football.
Why I'm starting him: It didn't take long into his career before Jonah Coleman became Denver's starting running back, even with an injury keeping him out for a month in the middle of it.
In the four games he played any real amount of time, Coleman's snap count has gone from 40 percent to 49, 66, and then 77 in Week 9. His role near the goal line and in the passing game has also gone up.
In Denver's last game, Coleman had a season-high 17 carries, plus a touchdown and four receptions. As Denver's starting running back against this struggling Raiders run defense, Coleman is a clear start this week in fantasy.
Fantasy outlook: RB2
Start 'Em: Jordyn Tyson
The matchup: The New Orleans Saints are facing the Chicago Bears this week. Chicago is one of the better defenses against wide receivers when it comes to fantasy football, giving up the 12th-fewest points to wide receivers.
However, they do give up the ninth-most yards per play through the air, which is important for the Saints in particular.
Why I'm starting him: Jordyn Tyson had a breakout game last week in his second career start. He had 11 receptions on 13 targets for 80 yards. Tyson had the same number of targets as the players who had the second, third, and fourth most targets on the team combined last week.
The reason the targets and passing yards per play are important for Tyson in this one is how the Bears play. Because they are so run-focused on offense, they tend to control the clock and limit possessions for their opponents.
Teams have had the fewest offensive plays against Chicago this season, at 471. The difference between the Bears at No. 32 and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers at No. 31 is the same difference between the Bucs and the 20th-ranked Rams.
So while Tyson and the Saints might not have a lot of plays overall in this one, he's going to have the target share and the potential for yardage (remember, Chicago gives up the ninth-most yards per pass play) to be viable in fantasy.
Fantasy Outlook: Flex
NFL rookie fantasy football sits for Week 11
Sit 'Em: Kaelon Black
The matchup: The San Francisco 49ers are facing the Minnesota Vikings in a pivotal regular-season matchup.
The Vikings are the best defense in the NFL this season, terrorizing teams with their blitzing up front and frantic coverage skills on the back end.
But their run defense is overlooked in all this. Teams have chances to run the ball on Minnesota since they are in so many low-scoring games, but they are 17th in rushing yards allowed and have given up just five rushing touchdowns all season, which is tied for third.
Due to the structure of their defense, they play with eight or more defenders in the box on run plays, and on those plays, they allow just 2.1 yards per carry, which is 10th in the league.
Why I'm sitting him: Kaelon Black had a good game last week against the Cowboys. He rushed 11 times for 53 yards and a touchdown. But a late-game fumble almost gave Dallas a chance to come back and win (Black did recover the fumble, though).
While the fumble might not decrease Black's looks in this game (although it might!), it's more about the matchup in this one. Dallas is one of the worst defenses in the league, especially against the run. Minnesota presents a much tougher challenge, especially for a running back still playing a complementary role.
Black has probably been the best running back the 49ers have drafted to complement Christian McCaffrey, but he hasn't had a true breakout game yet. After an average outing against the Cowboys last week, it's best to sit him out this week against such a tough matchup.
Fantasy outlook: Bench/stash
Sit 'Em: Seth McGowan
The matchup: The Indianapolis Colts are facing the Houston Texans this week in what turned out to be a sad divisional matchup between two teams with losing records.
Houston's defense has certainly been down this season (18th in scoring defense, 12th in DVOA) compared to last year (2nd and 2nd, respectively), but their run defense remains fairly stout. They are allowing the 11th-fewest rushing yards per game and are 15th in fantasy points allowed to running backs this season.
Why I'm sitting him: McGowan has been productive each of the last two weeks. He's had a touchdown in each game and produced 7.5 and 6.42 yards per attempt.
It was nice to see McGowan continue to get some run last week, receiving a season-high number of carries even after the threat of a Jonathan Taylor trade had passed.
But these last two games have been against very favorable matchups in Dallas and the Miami Dolphins. Both teams are in the top six in points allowed to running backs in fantasy.
Since McGowan is still seeing less than a third of the offensive snaps through this run, and the matchup will be tougher this week, don't count on McGowan's run to continue in fantasy.
Fantasy outlook: Bench/stash
Sit 'Em: Antonio Williams
The matchup: The Washington Commanders are facing the Cincinnati Bengals this week. The Bengals are giving up the 11th-fewest fantasy points to wide receivers this season.
Now that they have some semblance of a pass rush (14th in quarterback pressure rate), the talented cornerbacks for the Bengals, Dax Hill and DJ Turner, have been able to shine.
They are 11th in passing yards allowed and are tied for the fifth-fewest passing touchdowns given up this season.
Why I'm sitting him: Things have not really taken off for Williams as expected after the Terry McLaurin injury. In the three games since the injury and Washington's bye week, Williams has just 10 receptions for 121 yards and one touchdown.
He's become the third option in a passing offense that is average at best in most categories behind Stefon Diggs and Chig Okonkwo.
And despite the touchdown last week, he had just two total targets on the day, his lowest number of targets all season.
The tough matchup and overall role for Williams so far should keep him on your bench this week.
Fantasy outlook: Bench/stash
Rookie sleeper of the week: Makai Lemon

The matchup: The Philadelphia Eagles are facing the Pittsburgh Steelers in Week 11.
Pittsburgh is giving up the 19th most fantasy points to wide receivers this season. But after giving up a whopping 406 passing yards last week to the Bengals, they have now given up the third-most passing yards this season.
But things were already trending that way for Pittsburgh's pass defense. In their previous game before Cincinnati, they gave up a then-season-high 285 passing yards to the Cleveland Browns. And they've allowed 260 or more passing yards in six of their last seven games.
Why he's my sleeper: Since things have unraveled in Philadelphia, Makai Lemon has jumped in to fill the offensive void. Since Week 7, Lemon has had three straight games as WR1 while DeVonta Smith and Dontayvion Wicks have been injured.
In those games, Lemon has played more than 90 percent of snaps, seen at least eight targets, made at least six catches, and gone for at least 57 yards. He leads the team in all of those statistics over that stretch and has the only receiving touchdown.
Smith and Wicks both practiced in a limited capacity on Wednesday, and both seem to have a chance to play on Sunday. But if one, and definitely if both, end up being out, Lemon is a must-start in fantasy lineups.
Fantasy outlook: WR2 if Smith and Wicks are out, FLEX if one is out, potential bench option if both play.
