Skip to main content

2027 NFL Draft Power 5 QB rankings: New No. 1, familiar face returns to top 5

A new QB takes over No. 1 as a familiar name returns to the top five in the latest 2027 NFL Draft Power 5 rankings.
ByTarringo Basile-vaughan
Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr takes over the No. 1 spot in the latest 2027 NFL Draft Power 5 QB rankings following another consistent performance.
Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr takes over the No. 1 spot in the latest 2027 NFL Draft Power 5 QB rankings following another consistent performance. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The race to become QB1 in the 2027 NFL Draft continues to take unexpected turns. With some of the nation's top quarterback prospects struggling in Week 11, a new name rises to No. 1 in our NFL Mocks Power 5 rankings. But has anyone done enough to separate himself from the rest of the class?

While consistency is becoming a deciding factor at the top, a few quarterbacks are making their case with clutch performances despite their struggles. From a new leader to a familiar name returning to the top five, this week's rankings reflect just how wide open the QB1 race remains.

2027 NFL Draft QB rankings: The top 5

No. 1 CJ Carr, Notre Dame

A week after outdueling Darian Mensah, Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr is the top QB prospect in this week's Power 5.

While there wasn't much to marvel about in Notre Dame's 41-7 victory over Boston College in Week 11, Carr remains the most consistent of the top quarterback prospects eligible for the 2027 NFL Draft. Carr connected on 20 of 28 pass attempts for 217 yards with two touchdowns and one interception.

His overall performance included a 26-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver Micah Gilbert in the first quarter when the game was still in doubt, but the Fighting Irish didn't need much of Carr's arm in this one. The team dominated on the ground with 276 yards to fuel its offensive dominance.

Carr still stood out with the accuracy and command he is noted for and didn't hurt his draft stock at all.

The next test for Carr and Notre Dame is a Week 12 matchup against 7-3 SMU, a team that was ranked as high as No. 13 in the nation before dropping out of the national rankings following a brutal home loss to Wake Forest. This may be a sneaky big test for Carr and the Fighting Irish.

No. 2 Darian Mensah, Miami

Miami quarterback Darian Mensah looks to pass during a college football game.
Darian Mensah remains in the QB1 conversation following another productive performance for Miami. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Mensah didn't let the Week 10 loss to Notre Dame get him too down. In fact, he looked more motivated in the Week 11 matchup against his former team, the Duke Blue Devils.

This was a sneaky spot for Miami against the 7-3 Duke squad, but the Hurricanes were up for the challenge in running away with a 36-25 victory. Against his former team, Mensah completed 73.2 percent of his passes for 382 passing yards and a touchdown to help Miami improve to 9-1 on the season.

While arm strength and the deep ball are two areas of concern potentially holding Mensah back from being a top-five pick in the 2027 NFL Draft, the efficiency in his short-to-intermediate passes, along with his ability to spread the ball around, will have NFL teams highly intrigued by his potential, especially with playmakers around him who can create yards after the catch.

That's a big reason why I feel he would be a natural fit for the Cleveland Browns, who I had selecting him with their first pick in our recent 2027 NFL Mock Draft.

Like Carr, Mensah has been consistently good week after week, even while playing without one of the top wide receivers in the nation in Malachi Toney.

Next up for Mensah and the Hurricanes is a Week 12 matchup against Virginia Tech.

No. 3 Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma State

Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker prepares to throw a pass.
Drew Mestemaker slips to No. 3 in the 2027 NFL Draft Power 5 QB rankings after a difficult matchup against Texas Tech. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

After taking over No. 1 a few weeks ago in our NFL Mocks Power 5 rankings, Oklahoma State's Drew Mestemaker falls to No. 3 following a 52-27 loss to Texas Tech on Saturday.

Following a streak of eight consecutive games with at least 300 passing yards, Mestemaker saw that streak snapped against the Red Raiders, but just barely, as he still completed 27 of 42 passes for 277 yards and a touchdown. His two interceptions contributed to an early deficit the Cowboys attempted to climb out of after falling behind 21-0.

A trait of Mestemaker that NFL teams starving for a QB will love is his ability to bring his team back into a game. After falling behind 21-0, Mestemaker led his offense to 17 consecutive points to get back in the game. That was as close as the Cowboys came, as the Texas Tech pass rush eventually got the best of Mestemaker in this game.

For those believing Mestemaker needs another year in college, most will point to this game and how his post-snap reads under consistent pressure remain an area for improvement. Still, the overall talent is too hard to ignore.

Mestemaker looks to bounce back in Week 12 in a game at Arizona State.

No. 4 Jayden Maiava, USC

It wasn't a great game at all for Jayden Maiava, as No. 15 USC went down 27-13 at the hands of the No. 6 Indiana Hoosiers in Week 11.

But in this Power 5, we are measuring the overall body of work, and Maiava has been mostly consistent throughout the season in leading USC to some big wins, especially in the Big Ten.

In facing a tough task against the defending national champions, Maiava put up big numbers, throwing for 311 yards and a touchdown, but it was the three interceptions that hurt the offense.

Maiava also experienced red-zone struggles, highlighted by an interception at the 6-yard line with USC trailing just 20-13. It was a backbreaker for sure, and the game overall put some of Maiava's weaknesses in the spotlight, particularly his tendency to force throws with the game on the line.

Still, given his size, arm talent and ability to move the offense despite a lack of a consistent rushing attack, Maiava remains a QB prospect to keep your eyes on as a late-first-round option for quarterback-hungry teams.

Maiava will get a chance at redemption in a Saturday night matchup against Maryland in Week 12.

No. 5 Arch Manning, Texas

Texas quarterback Arch Manning looks downfield during a college football game.
Arch Manning returns to the top five as his late-game play continues to keep his 2027 NFL Draft potential in the spotlight. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Okay, Arch Manning didn't wow anyone with his Week 11 performance against No. 21 LSU, but with him, it's becoming more about how he finishes games.

In the Longhorns' 22-21 comeback victory over the Tigers, Manning completed 19 of 35 passes for 174 yards and a touchdown. His three interceptions and four sacks taken were reasons Texas couldn't get anything going offensively through most of the game, but neither Manning nor the Texas offense gave up.

Much like the win against Ohio State, Manning was able to put together a game-winning drive against a tough defense. On the final drive, Manning completed six of eight passes for 51 yards and rounded out the comeback with a 4-yard touchdown pass to running back Raleek Brown with the final seconds ticking off the clock.

On that final drive, Manning also converted two key third downs with his legs. Given his inconsistencies throughout the season, it is those types of drives that exemplify his talents.

Again, Manning didn't wow anyone, but with the struggles of other quarterbacks around the nation, he eases back into the Power 5 due to his clutch ability.

Can he put together a string of big performances to end the season and get his draft stock back up? With Texas taking on Arkansas in Week 12, he'll get an opportunity to start putting on a show.

Who could crash the top five?

As mentioned, it wasn't a great week for some of the top QB prospects eligible for the 2027 NFL Draft. Ole Miss star Trinidad Chambliss is always a threat for the top five, but he passed for just 127 yards in a road loss to Oklahoma in Week 11.

He did rush for 84 yards in the game, but if he had been able to do more in the passing game, Ole Miss may have had a better chance to get a win against the Sooners.

I do expect another big performance out of Chambliss that will catapult him into the Power 5 once again before the season is over.

One quarterback we've been watching here at NFL Mocks is South Carolina's LaNorris Sellers. He has the size, athleticism and arm talent to be special, but forced mistakes and injuries are holding him back.

Sellers missed his Week 11 matchup against Arkansas due to an ankle injury. If he can go in Week 12, he will have a big opportunity to raise his draft stock against No. 1 Georgia.

Talk about a big-time test.

Add us as a preferred source on Google