The 2025 All-Underrated Offensive Team highlights standout players like Damien Martinez and three LSU Tigers, all of whom are poised to exceed their draft expectations and make an impact at the next level.
For the past four years, NFL Mocks has released its All-Underrated Team, highlighting prospects who are overlooked in the draft process but have the potential to outperform expectations. Several past selections have gone on to impressive pro careers, including WR Puka Nacua, who has emerged as one of the NFL’s top young receivers, OT Alaric Jackson, who is set for a big payday in free agency despite going undrafted, and RB Bucky Irving, who led all rookies in rushing last season.
To qualify for this list, a player must have a NFL Mock Draft Database consensus draft grade below the second round and be projected to exceed expectations relative to their draft position.
Now, let’s unveil the 2025 All-Underrated Offensive Team.
2025 All-Underrated offense
QB: Kyle McCord, Syracuse
Kyle McCord is a quarterback who could present excellent value in the 2025 NFL Draft after a strong season at Syracuse following his transfer from Ohio State. This year, McCord led the nation in passing, breaking Syracuse's single-season records for yards, completions, and touchdown passes. His game is fundamentally sound, with impressive arm strength that allows him to challenge NFL-level defenses. If McCord continues to refine his decision-making, he has the potential to develop into a starting quarterback in a few years.
RB: Damien Martinez, Miami
Damien Martinez is a powerful, downhill runner with quick feet for his size (5-11, 226), drawing comparisons to former Chargers back Natrone Means. Over three seasons, he accumulated 3,169 rushing yards, averaging over 6 yards per carry each year. In 2024, he rushed for 1,002 yards and 10 touchdowns while forcing 42 missed tackles and averaging 4.46 yards after contact. Despite a consensus fifth-round grade, I have Martinez pegged as a third-round prospect due to his physicality and consistent production.
WR: Jack Bech, TCU
One player who had a standout season is TCU’s Jack Bech, who caught the game-winning touchdown in the Senior Bowl and saw a significant jump in production, going from just 28 receptions combined in 2023 and 2022 to 62 this season. What stands out most about Bech is his physical style of play, which enables him to make tough catches in heavy traffic. He also boasts some of the best hands in the class, having dropped only one pass all season.
A WALK-OFF WIN AT THE @SENIORBOWL!
— NFL Network (@nflnetwork) February 1, 2025
Seth Henigan finds Jack Bech for the American Team win! @MemphisFB @TCUFootball pic.twitter.com/Z04yGiQSVH
WR: Theo Wease Jr., Missouri
Theo Wease Jr. of Missouri is one of two wide receivers on this team with a consensus draft grade of undrafted free agent. Despite sharing the field with potential top-ten pick Luther Burden III, Wease led the Tigers with 884 receiving yards this past season. While he may not have elite speed, his toughness, reliable hands, and overall strength make him a strong candidate to earn a spot on an NFL roster as a fourth or fifth wide receiver.
Slot: Junior Bergen, Montana
Junior Bergen of Montana is a player who has been largely overlooked but has consistently stood out at the FCS level, both as a receiver and a return man. As a receiver, he’s dynamic with the ball in his hands and displays impressive strength for his size. However, his top trait is his special teams ability, where he’s truly exceptional. This season, he averaged an impressive 24 yards per punt return and scored three touchdowns on just 10 returns. Over the course of his career, he’s taken eight punts back for touchdowns. Expect a team to draft Bergen late in the NFL Draft or sign him as an undrafted free agent, and they’ll be thrilled with the impact he can make as a special teams ace.
TE: Mason Taylor, LSU
Mason Taylor of LSU is one of the highest-rated players on my overall board to make this team, holding a first-round grade—significantly higher than his third-round consensus draft grade. What stands out to me is his rare blend of size and athleticism. Over his career at LSU, he’s made numerous tough catches and set school records for tight ends with 129 receptions and 1,308 receiving yards.
OT: Emery Jones Jr., OT, LSU
LSU’s Emery Jones Jr. is a player who may now be underrated after a down year. Once viewed as a potential top-10 pick, he now holds a consensus third-round draft grade. The biggest reason for his drop in stock is his inconsistent technique, but with the right coaching, he has the strength, athleticism, and character to develop into a quality NFL starter.
"He makes good choices, good decisions. He is never late to anything. He is reliable. This is a guy that we can count on. He is so reliable and that goes to his background, his family, and his high school. He is exceptional."LSU head coach Brian Kelly
OG: Garrett Dellinger, LSU
The third and final LSU Tiger to make the All-Underrated Team is offensive guard Garrett Dellinger. Over the past two seasons, he has allowed just one sack while also proving to be an underrated run blocker. His greatest asset is his strength, making him a strong fit for teams that utilize a gap-blocking scheme. He should be a solid target on the third day of the draft.
C: Jared Wilson, Georgia
In his first season as a starter, Georgia's Jared Wilson established himself as one of the top centers in the 2025 NFL Draft. He earned second-team All-SEC honors while allowing zero sacks and just six pressures throughout the season. Wilson showcased the elite mobility and athleticism that NFL offensive line coaches covet. With more experience, he has the potential to become a Pro Bowler, particularly for teams that favor zone-blocking schemes.
"I'm excited for the rest of the world to get to see Jared Wilson He has a lot to do to be the best player he can be, but when you talk about athleticism at the center position, this guy runs faster than a lot of our defensive backs, believe it or not, our tight ends, our quarterbacks. His numbers, extremely athletic, over 300 pounds, can get to the second level as quick as anybody. Just really athletic."Georgia head coach Kirby Smart
OG: Connor Colby, Iowa
Heading into the 2023 season, Iowa’s Connor Colby was labeled NFL Mocks’ most overrated offensive guard, but he finishes his college career as a member of the All-Underrated Team. This shift is largely due to his standout final season, where he earned first-team All-Big Ten honors. Despite this achievement, his draft stock has fallen among analysts, landing him a consensus sixth-round grade. I see him as a high Day 3 pick, valuing his mobility and extensive experience, as he has made the second-most starts (50) of any offensive lineman in the Kirk Ferentz era.
OT: Anthony Belton, North Carolina State
One of the biggest tackles in the 2025 NFL Draft, North Carolina State’s Anthony Belton stands at 6-foot-5 and 345 pounds. Despite his massive frame, he moves surprisingly well, which has led NFL coaches to believe he has the potential to develop into a starting right tackle at the next level. However, to reach that ceiling, he needs to refine his run blocking—particularly improving his hand usage and keeping his feet moving on contact.
Stay tuned for the 2025 All-Underrated Defensive Team, which will be released just before the draft in April.