As great as Elway was, there can be no disputing the fact that Peyton Manning was greater, and is the greatest #1 pick of all-time. The stats alone bear this out: 6,774 completions, 79,279 passing yards, 579 touchdown passes, 47 comebacks in the 4th quarter. All of them are NFL records. He has seven touchdown passes in a single game (a record), 55 in a season (a record) and led the highest-scoring offense in NFL history that scored 606 points in just 16 games. The man was a machine on Sundays and nearly unstoppable even into his late 30s despite undergoing four surgeries on his neck.
<p> </p>
<p>Perhaps his greatest feat though is what he accomplished in the win column. Manning is the only quarterback to ever reach the Super Bowl with four different head coaches. For all the love Tom Brady gets, he never had to deal with such upheaval his entire career, and Manning made such transitions look routine. He is the only player in history to win five MVP awards and went to 14 Pro Bowls. To top it all off, he has a Super Bowl ring from two different franchises. There isn’t another man on this list who comes even close to that level of personal success.</p>. QB. Tennessee. Peyton Manning . 1. player. 46